2025-02-26
Signal Opposes Sweden's Proposed E2EE Backdoor
"We would leave the market before we would comply with something that would catastrophically undermine our ability to provide private communications ... We have a responsibility to provide technology that upholds human rights in an era where those rights are being infringed on in many, many corners," said Meredith Whittaker, president of the parent non-profit behind encrypted messaging service Signal, in an interview with Swedish publication SVT Nyheter. Whittaker's ultimatum is a response to a proposed bill in Swedish parliament that would require Signal and Meta's WhatsApp to "store chat data for up to two years and make it available to law enforcement officials upon request." The bill could go before the legislature as early as March 2026. SVT Nyheter also reports that Sweden's armed forces rely on Signal and have submitted a letter warning the government against the risks of weakening encrypted communication.
Editor's Note
Requests for encryption back doors are concerning on many levels, as the likelihood that such mechanisms would be restricted to specific use cases is nonexistent. The idea with E2EE is nobody, including the service providers, other than the recipient can access the content. While the Swedish legislation includes a 'where technically feasible' clause, it's not clear that will help in this case, and exiting this market may be Signal's best play.

Lee Neely
In the face of Salt Typhoon and other breaches, one must be naive to believe that access to such a capability can be restricted to legitimate law enforcement activity. It is not as though our infrastructure is not already sufficiently porous without nation states actively striving to make it more so. One's working assumption must be that nation states can already read any traffic that they want to but cannot read all the traffic that they want to. Therefore, one is led to infer that the intent goes to efficient, broad, secret, and warrantless surveillance.

William Hugh Murray
Dovetailing on last week's conversation with Backdoors in Encryption is not ideal. We haven't learned from CALEA and Lawful Intercept. Apple went away from the UK. The only recourse I see is Signal not allowing Swedish users. Interestingly, the Swedish military is asking their government not to do this. This is a patchwork of E2E hell, and I see more and more governments requesting the same thing happening more and more. What's inconvenient is when the actual 'Bad Guys (tm)' start to use their own E2E messaging systems that do not have any sovereign country to ask to open a backdoor.

Moses Frost
The right response from Signal. While the focus is on Signal and WhatsApp, the law might ensnare other E2EE applications like AAPL iMessage, FaceTime, and password managers. Let's see if the Swedish Riksdag blinks.
