2025-02-10
UK Demands Government Backdoor in Apple's E2EE
The UK's Home Office has reportedly served a Technical Capability Notice (TCN) under the Investigatory Powers Act (IPA) compelling Apple to give the government backdoor access to worldwide users' encrypted data in the company's cloud service. Although "under the law, the demand cannot be made public," and while the Home Office will neither confirm nor deny "any such notices," both the Washington Post, who first reported the news, and the BBC have spoken with anonymous "sources familiar with the matter." The alleged demand specifically targets Apple's end-to-end encrypted Advanced Data Protection (ADP) measures, and may apply in cases of national security risk, requiring a legal permission process to access the backdoor. Apple's history with similar cases and the company's prior statements show a pattern of opposing or refusing such demands. In the UK specifically, out of over 6,000 requests for iCloud data between 2020 and 2023, Apple complied only four times. Cybersecurity experts and privacy groups have expressed deep concern over the serious risks to users' security and privacy posed by breaking encryption with backdoors; the Electronic Frontier Foundation notes that "any 'backdoor' built for the government puts everyone at greater risk of hacking, identity theft, and fraud," and the UK's Big Brother Watch states that such a backdoor "will not make the UK safer, but it will erode the fundamental rights and civil liberties of the entire population."
Editor's Note
It seems that the UK government and its advisors have not being paying attention to the recent Salt Typhoon attacks against US telcos where lawful intercept capabilities built into those networks were abused by hostile nation state actors to intercept traffic travelling over those networks. As I have said many times, "we can have strong encryption and accept that the cost will be its abuse by criminals while the internet is made more secure, or we can weaken encryption and accept that the cost will be its abuse by criminals while the internet is made insecure."

Brian Honan
Governments will never learn from past failures in implementing 'back doors' in communication infrastructure. Proposing this before 'Volt Typhoon' is even fully evicted (or even identified as far as the UK is concerned) is actually kind of funny.

Johannes Ullrich
Encryption with a "government/law enforcement" backdoor is an oxymoron. Remember the clipper chip? We've seen this movie before, there is no effective way to restrict access to that back door, let alone prevent others from reverse engineering it. The concerns over decrypting iCloud data were exacerbated with the introduction of Advanced Data Protection for iCloud in iOS 16 which enables end-to-end for the majority of your iCloud data, and not even Apple can access this data.

Lee Neely
If you thought the Cryptography War ended with Salt Typhoon, think again. Apparently governments will never gracefully consent to private communications for their citizens. As one might infer from Salt Typhoon, any such backdoor will become the target of choice for all the resources of China, Israel, Iran, Russia, and North Korea, not to mention NSA. It is unlikely that Scotland Yard, Special Branch, MI5, and GCHQ can protect any such backdoor better than the FBI, NSA, and the Telcos were able to protect CALEA. Such a facility, justified by terrorism and crime, will inevitably be used for surveillance, not limited to His Majesty's subjects.

William Hugh Murray
Everyone is watching how Apple will handle this. A backdoor for the UK government is a universal backdoor for everyone. At least that's what it would appear on the surface. I don't know how that will work or if Apple will be okay with it. If you want to know what these backdoors can be used for just follow Salt Typhoon, CALEA, and all that mess.

Moses Frost
Apple has been at the forefront in protecting the communication of users of its products. It was only a matter of time before some Government would demand access for national security purposes. One can understand the arguments, and each are valid. What's particularly interesting is the reach of the Investigatory Powers Act. If successful, other nations will surely follow in the UKÕs footsteps.

Curtis Dukes
Read more in
BBC: UK demands access to Apple users' encrypted data
The Record: UK reportedly demands secret 'back door' to Apple users' iCloud accounts
The Record: Out of 6,000 requests, Apple provided UK with iCloud data only four times since 2020
EFF: The UK's Demands for Apple to Break Encryption Is an Emergency for Us All
TechCrunch: UK's secret Apple iCloud backdoor order is a global emergency, say critics